Summary
The school asked a simple question: what do we actually have, and does it work? Nobody on site knew. The systems had been added by three installers over eleven years, and the last one had stopped answering the phone.
What we found
- 56 devices across four systems. 40 work as they should, 9 are degraded and 7 have failed.
- The main recorder has recorded nothing since March. It looked fine, because live pictures still showed.
- The school could not log in to its own recorder, switches or door system. All have been recovered without a reset.
- 6 devices on default passwords, one recorder open to the internet, and 37 fobs still active for people who have left.
What it means
- Most of the estate is sound. It does not need replacing.
- Four items were put right on the day, at no extra cost.
- The rest is a phased list totalling £6,110, starting with £680 in the first 30 days.
- A new CCTV system of this size would typically budget at £12,000 to £20,000 (Cost Estimator, 32-camera band).
| System | Devices | Working | Degraded | Failed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CCTV | 26 | 15 | 6 | 5 |
| Access control | 10 | 9 | 1 | 0 |
| Intruder alarm | 17 | 14 | 1 | 2 |
| Network | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| Whole estate | 56 | 40 | 9 | 7 |
Asset register
Every device found, tested and logged. The school keeps this as a spreadsheet. Each device has a reference that matches the label fixed to it on site and the entry for its password in the school's own vault.
In this example, makes, models, serial numbers and network addresses are left out. A real register records them in full for every device.
Showing all 56 devices
Swipe the table sideways to read the engineer's notes.
| Reference | System | Device | Location | Condition | Firmware | Admin access | Engineer's note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AV-CAM-01 | CCTV | Camera | Front gate | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Clear day and night image. |
| AV-CAM-02 | CCTV | Camera | Main entrance | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Clear day and night image. |
| AV-CAM-03 | CCTV | Camera | Reception interior | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-04 | CCTV | Camera | Car park east | Degraded | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Infrared failed. No usable image after dark. |
| AV-CAM-05 | CCTV | Camera | Car park west | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-06 | CCTV | Camera | Rear gate | Failed | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Offline since July according to the recorder log. Water in the connector. |
| AV-CAM-07 | CCTV | Camera | Residential Road boundary | Failed | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Offline. Cable damaged where it crosses the fence line. |
| AV-CAM-08 | CCTV | Camera | Front courtyard | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-09 | CCTV | Camera | Science block yard | Degraded | 3+ years behind | Held by school | Lens obscured and out of focus. Faces not identifiable. |
| AV-CAM-10 | CCTV | Camera | Science block door | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-11 | CCTV | Camera | Main building corridor, ground floor | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-12 | CCTV | Camera | Main building corridor, first floor | Working | 3+ years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-13 | CCTV | Camera | Staff entrance | Degraded | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | Knocked out of position. Now views a wall. |
| AV-CAM-14 | CCTV | Camera | Bike store | Failed | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | Camera dead. Network port tested and working. |
| AV-CAM-15 | CCTV | Camera | Field boundary | Degraded | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | Night image unusable. |
| AV-CAM-16 | CCTV | Camera | Canteen | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-17 | CCTV | Camera | Sports hall entrance | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Was default. Changed | Default password in use. |
| AV-CAM-18 | CCTV | Camera | Sports hall interior | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Was default. Changed | Default password in use. |
| AV-CAM-19 | CCTV | Camera | Sports hall rear fire exit | Failed | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | No power at the camera. |
| AV-CAM-20 | CCTV | Camera | Sports hall, field side | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Was default. Changed | Default password in use. |
| AV-CAM-21 | CCTV | Camera | PE store corridor | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Held by school | |
| AV-CAM-22 | CCTV | Camera | Sports hall plant room door | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Was default. Changed | Default password in use. |
| AV-CAM-23 | CCTV | Camera | Sixth form entrance | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Was default. Changed | Default password in use. |
| AV-CAM-24 | CCTV | Camera | Library | Degraded | Unsupported | Held by school | Drops out intermittently. Model no longer supported by its manufacturer. |
| AV-NVR-1 | CCTV | Recorder, 16 channel | Comms room | Failed | 3+ years behind | Recovered | Live view works. Nothing recorded since 14 March. Both hard disks have failed. |
| AV-NVR-2 | CCTV | Recorder, 8 channel | Sports hall office | Degraded | 3+ years behind | Was default. Changed | Recording, but only 9 days are kept against 31 in the CCTV policy. Default admin password. |
| AV-SW-1 | Network | PoE switch, 24 port | Comms room | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Recovered | |
| AV-SW-2 | Network | PoE switch, 8 port | Science block riser | Working | 1 to 3 years behind | Recovered | |
| AV-SW-3 | Network | PoE switch, 8 port | Sports hall office | Degraded | Not applicable | Not applicable | Unmanaged consumer-grade switch. One port has failed. |
| AV-ACS-1 | Access control | Management software | Office PC | Working | 3+ years behind | Recovered | Admin login was held only by the previous installer. |
| AV-DC-1 | Access control | Door controller, 2 door | Comms room | Working | 3+ years behind | Recovered | Main entrance and reception inner door. |
| AV-DC-2 | Access control | Door controller, 2 door | Science block riser | Working | 3+ years behind | Recovered | Science block door and staff entrance. Door-held-open alarm had been switched off. |
| AV-DC-3 | Access control | Door controller, 2 door | Sports hall office | Degraded | 3+ years behind | Recovered | Sports hall lock releases intermittently. |
| AV-RDR-01 | Access control | Reader | Main entrance | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-RDR-02 | Access control | Reader | Reception inner door | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-RDR-03 | Access control | Reader | Science block door | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-RDR-04 | Access control | Reader | Staff entrance | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-RDR-05 | Access control | Reader | Sports hall | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-RDR-06 | Access control | Reader | Comms room | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-IA-1 | Intruder alarm | Control panel | Office | Degraded | Not applicable | With alarm maintainer | Standby battery dated 2019. Failed its load test. |
| AV-KP-1 | Intruder alarm | Keypad | Main entrance | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-KP-2 | Intruder alarm | Keypad | Staff entrance | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-01 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Reception | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-02 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Office | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-03 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Head's office | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-04 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Staff room | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-05 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Comms room | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-06 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Library | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-07 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | ICT suite | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-08 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Art room | Failed | Not applicable | Not applicable | Failed the walk test. |
| AV-DET-09 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Science prep room | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-10 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Canteen | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-DET-11 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Sports hall store | Failed | Not applicable | Not applicable | Failed the walk test. |
| AV-DET-12 | Intruder alarm | Movement detector | Sixth form common room | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-SND-1 | Intruder alarm | External sounder | Front elevation | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
| AV-COM-1 | Intruder alarm | Signalling unit | Office | Working | Not applicable | Not applicable | Signal path tested. Police response status to be confirmed with the alarm receiving centre. |
Findings
12 findings, ranked by risk: 4 high, 5 medium and 3 low. Each one points back to the register, so anyone can check it.
- 01High
The main recorder has not recorded since 14 March
AV-NVR-1 shows live pictures, so nobody noticed. Both hard disks have failed. Sixteen cameras have produced no footage for months.
Register reference: AV-NVR-1
- 02High
The main recorder can be reached from the internet
A port was opened on the school firewall by the previous installer for remote viewing and never closed. The recorder is running firmware more than three years old.
Register reference: AV-NVR-1
- 03High
Default passwords on 6 devices
The sports hall recorder and 5 cameras still use the manufacturer's default admin password, which is published online.
Register reference: AV-NVR-2 and five cameras
- 04High
37 active fobs belong to people who have left
Of 212 active credentials, 37 belong to former staff and contractors. One contractor fob issued last year still opens the science block door.
Register reference: AV-ACS-1
- 05Medium
4 cameras are offline, including the rear gate
The rear gate camera has been offline since July. The recorder logged the loss, but no alert was set up to tell anyone.
Register reference: AV-CAM-06, 07, 14, 19
- 06Medium
Firmware is more than three years behind on 18 devices
Known vulnerabilities have been fixed by the manufacturers in later versions. 1 camera is a model that no longer receives updates at all.
Register reference: See register
- 07Medium
Footage is kept for 9 days, not the 31 in the CCTV policy
The sports hall recorder does not have the storage to meet the retention period the school has published. The policy and the system need to agree.
Register reference: AV-NVR-2
- 08Medium
Nobody at the school could log in to the door system
The only admin account belonged to the previous installer. The school could not add or remove a fob without them.
Register reference: AV-ACS-1
- 09Medium
Intruder alarm battery and two detectors have failed
The panel would not ride through a power cut, and two rooms are not covered. This work must stay with a certified alarm company (see the note on police response).
Register reference: AV-IA-1, AV-DET-08, 11
- 10Low
5 cameras give a degraded picture
Failed infrared, a dirty lens, one camera knocked out of position and one that drops out. Most are a service visit, not a replacement.
Register reference: AV-CAM-04, 09, 13, 15, 24
- 11Low
Recorder clocks were seven minutes out
Footage with the wrong time is harder to use as evidence and harder to match against door events.
Register reference: AV-NVR-1, AV-NVR-2
- 12Low
No asset register, drawings or handover documents existed
Nothing recorded what was installed, where, or who held the passwords. This pack is now that record.
Register reference: Whole estate
Access regained, without a reset
Admin access to 7 devices was recovered through each manufacturer's own route, so no footage or settings were lost. Every new password sits in a vault the school controls, with a record of who holds what. Where a reset would have been the only way in, we would have said first what it would erase and waited for written agreement.
Police response and the intruder alarm
A police response number needs the alarm maintained by an NSI or SSAIB certified company. Fyrfly does not currently hold that certification. We tested and reported on the alarm, but the repairs stay with the school's certified maintainer so police response is not put at risk. We wrote the job sheet for them.
Signed baseline
The condition of the estate on the day of the audit, agreed in writing by both sides. Any maintenance contract that follows is measured against it, and it settles in advance what was already broken.
On the date of this audit the security estate at Ashcombe Vale Academy comprised 56 devices, of which 40 were working, 9 were degraded and 7 had failed, as listed in the asset register (Part 2).
The 12 findings in Part 3 existed before the audit and are recorded as pre-existing. The four items marked "Done during the audit" in Part 5 were corrected on the day and are recorded as resolved.
The asset register, the recovered credentials and this report belong to the school, whether or not it goes on to a maintenance contract with Fyrfly Systems.
Costed fix list
Prioritised by risk and phased to the school's budget cycle. Costs are for supply, fitting and testing, before VAT. They are illustrative figures for this example, not a quotation.
Now: within 30 days
Close the exposures and get the site recording again.
| Replace both hard disks in the main recorder, restore recording, set 31-day retention and switch on email health alerts | £520 |
| Close the open firewall port and set up secure remote viewing for named staff | £160 |
| Change the default password on 6 devices and store the new ones in the school's vault | Done during the audit |
| Remove 37 leaver and contractor credentials, from a list agreed with the school first | Done during the audit |
| Synchronise both recorder clocks to network time | Done during the audit |
| Switch the door-held-open alarm back on at the science block door | Done during the audit |
| Intruder alarm: replace the standby battery and two failed detectors. Job sheet written for the school's certified alarm maintainer | Referred |
| Phase 1 total | £680 |
This financial year
Restore full coverage and bring everything up to date.
| Replace 4 failed cameras on the existing cabling, including the rear gate, and repair the boundary cable | £1,680 |
| Clean, refocus and realign two cameras. Replace two with failed infrared | £560 |
| Update firmware on every supported device, staged, with a tested way back | £380 |
| Add storage to the sports hall recorder so it keeps 31 days | £310 |
| Replace the sports hall door lock | £290 |
| Replace the unmanaged sports hall switch with a managed one | £340 |
| Phase 2 total | £3,560 |
Next budget cycle
Planned replacements, so nothing fails without warning.
| Replace the unsupported library camera and the ageing sports hall recorder | £1,450 |
| Live camera view at the reception desk, so alerts can be checked where decisions are made | £420 |
| Phase 3 total | £1,870 |
Leave alone
Where the right answer is to do nothing, the list says so. At Ashcombe Vale that covers most of the estate.
- All structured cabling, which tested sound
- 15 cameras giving a clear picture
- The main recorder chassis, which is serviceable once its disks are replaced
- All three door controllers and all six readers
- The intruder alarm panel, keypads and ten working detectors
The audit itself is a fixed price, quoted per site from the number and type of devices. If the school goes on to a maintenance contract with Fyrfly, the fee is credited in full against the first year.
Summary for governors
One page for the governing body or trust board, written for people who do not need to know what firmware is.
Where we stand
| System | Status | In one line |
|---|---|---|
| CCTV | Red | Not recording on the main recorder. Four cameras offline. |
| Access control | Amber | Hardware sound. Credentials were out of control and are now cleaned up. |
| Intruder alarm | Amber | Working, but would not survive a power cut. Two rooms uncovered. |
| Network | Amber | Sound, with one switch to replace. |
What governors should know
- For eight months the main CCTV recorder kept no footage, and nobody knew. Had there been an incident, there would have been nothing to give the police.
- The school publishes a 31-day retention period in its CCTV policy. Part of the system keeps 9 days. The policy and the system must be brought into line.
- 37 former staff and contractors could still open doors. That has been corrected, and a leaver process is needed so it stays corrected.
- The equipment is mostly sound. The problem was that nothing and nobody was checking it.
Decisions requested
- Approve Phase 1 spend of £680 now, and note Phase 2 (£3,560) for this financial year.
- Adopt a leaver process, so door credentials are removed on the day someone leaves.
- Name a governor to see evidence of maintenance and testing once a year.
This audit reports the condition of security equipment. It is not a compliance certificate and does not by itself show that the school meets Martyn's Law, KCSiE or UK GDPR. For a review against those, see the Annual Security Audit.